Majilis Deputy Calls for Reform of Kazakhstan's Fine System

Deputy Askhat Aimagambetov has stated that fines should be reasonable, proportionate, and focused on solving problems rather than budget revenue, Orda.kz reports.

Writing on his Telegram channel, the Majilis member expressed concern that the administrative penalty system is straying from its primary purpose of prevention and correction, becoming instead a mere revenue-generating tool.

Aimagambetov warns that government agencies must recognize the dangers of this "fine-centric narrative," as it undermines public trust in administrative accountability.

He highlighted several problematic examples:

• School heads facing fines of 600,000-900,000 tenge for systemic issues beyond their control, such as three-shift operations and lack of equipment
• Parking violations where fines are 200 times the original parking fee of 100 tenge
• Outdated regulations

To improve the system, Aimagambetov proposes:

• Revising fines to ensure proportionality with violations
• Addressing systemic problems at the funding body level rather than punishing local administrators
• Implementing alternative penalties such as educational courses and community service
• Earmarking fine revenue for specific social causes like cancer treatment or school construction
• Creating a more balanced and fair approach to minor violations

Fines are unpleasant, but an unavoidable measure, since it is important to prevent violations and hold those responsible accountable. The neologism 'Finestan' and the given narrative pose a threat to the institution of administrative penalties. The key is to maintain a balance so that the measures always remain proportionate and fair, concluded Aimagambetov.

Original Author: Rimma Karatayeva