Adil Soz Criticizes Deputy PM’s Conduct Toward Journalists

Karlygash Dzhamankulova, head of the Adil Soz Foundation for the Protection of Freedom of Speech, has commented on the conduct of Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Economy Serik Zhumangarin during a recent briefing, Orda.kz reports.

The incident took place on June 23 during a Senate press event. When a BES.media journalist asked Zhumangarin to name the company that allegedly avoided more than 200 billion tenge in taxes through the AIFC, he turned off the microphone and left the briefing.

Dzhamankulova offered three key points regarding the official’s behavior, which she said undermines open communication between the government and the public.

She referenced a statement by President Qasym-Jomart Toqayev, who described himself as a manager hired by the people, not a divine messenger.

Dzhamankulova contrasted this with what she described as Zhumangarin’s dismissive public conduct.

Apparently, Mr. Zhumangarin is above such reasoning. And above the Ethical Code of Civil Servants of the Republic of Kazakhstan, according to Article 5 of which civil servants are obliged to adhere to the principle of openness (that is, to be ready to work with the public and ensure transparency of actions), as well as the principle of politeness, which implies a correct and respectful attitude towards citizens and control institutions,
 she stated.

Dzhamankulova called on the Civil Service Agency to evaluate the minister’s conduct.

Her second point emphasized that officials’ actions in public cannot be treated as private behavior, as they influence public perception.

Disrespect for journalists, ignoring uncomfortable questions and trying to avoid accountability – all this undermines trust in the government and contradicts the principle of transparent governance. When one part of the state apparatus spends resources on promoting open dialogue, and another sabotages it, we are faced with an erosion of trust in the very logic of public policy,
Dzhamankulova said.

The third point focused on the public nature of the incident and Zhumangarin’s role in overseeing the new Tax Code.

Is the code really negotiated and agreed upon with the business community? If he is not shy about avoiding a simple answer on camera, does he behave with more respect behind closed doors? Why couldn't he answer the question of the BES.media journalist?
 she asked.

Dzhamankulova suggested that a full press conference may help address the situation, noting the importance of journalists receiving proper answers.

Journalists responded to Dzhamankulova’s post, noting similar experiences with the Deputy Prime Minister.

The Orda.kz editorial team will continue monitoring any official response.

Original Author: Alexandra Mokhireva